Alright, settle in, because today, we’re going to talk about a disappearance that is, without a doubt, one of the most baffling, frustrating, and utterly chilling mysteries of the 20th century. It’s a story that involves three women, a seemingly ordinary home, and a vanishing act so complete, so impossible, that it continues to haunt a community and a grieving family to this very day.
This is the strange, dark, and mysterious case of The Springfield Three. And trust me, you’re going to be scratching your head long after this story is over.
Now, if you find yourself drawn to these kinds of unexplained enigmas, do me a quick favor and consider hitting that like button. It truly helps the channel, and it lets me know you’re ready for more stories that defy all logic.
A Night of Celebration – And a Sleepover
Our story begins in Springfield, Missouri, in the early summer of 1992. The air was warm, graduation season was in full swing, and life felt full of possibility. Our main characters are three women, each with their own dreams and plans.
First, there’s Sherrill Levitt. She was 47 years old, a warm and loving single mother, a hairdresser by profession, known for her kindness and her strong bond with her daughter. She lived in a modest home at 1737 East Delmar Street in Springfield.
Then there’s Sherrill’s daughter, Suzie Streeter. Suzie was 19 years old, vibrant and energetic, a recent high school graduate. She was looking forward to her future, perhaps college, perhaps a career. She was full of that youthful optimism that comes with new beginnings.
And finally, there’s Stacy McCall. Stacy was also 18 years old, another recent high school graduate, and Suzie’s best friend. She was planning to attend Southwest Missouri State University in the fall. She was a bright, popular young woman, excited about her future.
The night of Saturday, June 6, 1992, was supposed to be a night of celebration. Both Suzie and Stacy had just graduated from Kickapoo High School. They had spent the day at various graduation parties, celebrating with friends. As the evening wore on, they decided to have a sleepover at Sherrill Levitt’s house. It was a common, innocent plan for two best friends.
The last known sightings of Suzie and Stacy were around 2:00 AM on Sunday, June 7th. They were seen leaving a party at a friend’s house. They then drove back to Sherrill’s home, arriving sometime in the early hours of the morning. Sherrill herself was likely already asleep in her bed. The house was quiet, the neighborhood peaceful.
It was a perfectly normal, quiet night. But this seemingly ordinary night was about to take a terrifying, inexplicable turn.
The Morning Discovery – A Scene Frozen in Time
The first sign that something was terribly wrong came on Sunday morning, June 7, 1992. Stacy McCall’s mother, Janis, was expecting Stacy to be home by noon to get ready for another graduation party. When Stacy didn’t show up, and Janis couldn’t reach her by phone, she grew concerned. This wasn’t like Stacy.
Janis, accompanied by Stacy’s boyfriend, drove to Sherrill Levitt’s house. They arrived around noon. What they found immediately struck them as odd, then unsettling, and finally, terrifying.
The front door of Sherrill’s house was unlocked. It was standing slightly ajar. This was unusual for Sherrill, who was known to be very careful about locking her doors.
They cautiously entered the house. The scene inside was chilling, almost like a snapshot frozen in time, but with the main subjects missing. The lights were on. The television was on, tuned to a local news channel. It was as if someone had simply stepped away for a moment, but never returned.
Suzie Streeter’s dog, a small terrier mix named Cinnamon, was inside the house. She was agitated, barking nervously, pacing back and forth. This was also strange; Cinnamon was usually a calm dog.
As they walked through the house, the strangeness only deepened. Sherrill Levitt’s bed had been slept in, the covers turned back, but she wasn’t in it. In Suzie’s room, Stacy McCall’s clothes were neatly folded on the bed, along with her jewelry, as if she had just changed. Suzie’s bed also appeared to have been slept in.
The kitchen was clean, with no dirty dishes or signs of a struggle. The only thing out of place was a broken porch light on the front porch, its glass shattered on the ground.
Both Sherrill’s car and Suzie’s car were still parked outside the house. Nothing seemed to be missing from the house itself. No money, no valuables, no electronics. There were no signs of forced entry, no broken windows, no ransacked rooms. There was no blood, no struggle, no clear evidence of a crime. It was eerily quiet, save for the nervous barking of Cinnamon.
Janis McCall immediately called the police. Three women – a mother, her daughter, and her daughter’s best friend – had simply vanished from a locked house in the middle of the night, leaving behind a scene that defied all logic.
The Initial Investigation – A Ghostly Absence
When the Springfield Police Department arrived, they were faced with a truly perplexing situation. They had three missing adults, but no clear evidence of what had happened. There were no signs of a struggle, no forced entry, no obvious crime scene. It was as if the women had evaporated.
The police began their investigation, but they were already at a disadvantage. Without a clear crime, without a body, without a suspect, they had very little to go on. They interviewed neighbors, friends, and family, trying to piece together the events of that night.
A few more strange details emerged during the initial investigation:
One of Sherrill Levitt’s house keys was missing from her keyring. This suggested that whoever entered the house might have had a key, or taken one.
There was also a strange message on Sherrill’s answering machine. It was a garbled, distorted message, possibly from a man. It was later accidentally erased by a police officer, a tragic mistake that removed a potentially crucial piece of evidence.
The police also received an anonymous phone call to their tip line a few days after the disappearance. A man claimed that the three women had been tied up and taken to a specific location. The police investigated, but the tip proved to be false, or at least, unverifiable. It was a frustrating dead end, typical of a case with so few concrete leads.
The search for the Springfield Three began immediately. Police, volunteers, and search and rescue teams scoured the area around Sherrill’s home. They searched the woods, the fields, the waterways. They put up flyers, contacted media outlets, and appealed to the public for any information.
But they found nothing. No trace of Sherrill, Suzie, or Stacy. No discarded clothing, no personal items, no signs of a struggle in the surrounding area. It was as if they had simply vanished into thin air.
The Lingering Questions – A Decade of Silence
As days turned into weeks, weeks into months, and months into years, the case of The Springfield Three grew colder. The initial flurry of activity gave way to a quiet, agonizing wait for answers that never came. The questions continued to pile up, each one more frustrating than the last.
How could three women disappear from a house with no signs of forced entry or struggle?
If they left voluntarily, why leave everything behind – their cars, their clothes, their money, their pets? Why would they abandon their lives without a word to anyone?
If they were abducted, how was it done so silently, so efficiently, without waking anyone, without leaving any evidence?
What was the significance of the broken porch light? Was it broken during a struggle, or was it a deliberate act to make the house darker?
What about that missing key? Did someone they knew have access to the house?
And what about that erased answering machine message? Could it have held the key to the entire mystery?
The lack of any definitive evidence, any body, any confirmed sighting, has made The Springfield Three one of the most enduring and frustrating cold cases in American history. It’s a case where the absence of evidence is, in itself, the most chilling clue.
The Theories – Whispers in the Wind
With no clear answers, countless theories have emerged over the years, each trying to explain the impossible vanishing of The Springfield Three.
One of the most prominent theories, and the one most feared by the families, is that the women were abducted and murdered. The idea here is that someone, or perhaps a group of people, entered the house, took the three women, and then disposed of their bodies in a way that left no trace. This would explain their complete disappearance. The lack of struggle could suggest they were surprised, or perhaps taken by someone they knew and trusted, which would explain the unlocked door and the lack of forced entry. But the sheer perfection of the crime, leaving absolutely no forensic evidence, no blood, no fibers, no DNA, is incredibly rare and points to a highly professional or incredibly lucky perpetrator.
Then there’s the theory that the women were victims of a serial killer or a transient perpetrator. Springfield, being a crossroads city, sees a lot of transient populations. Perhaps a drifter, or someone passing through, stumbled upon the house and committed an opportunistic crime. This could explain the lack of a direct connection to the victims. However, again, the lack of evidence remains a huge hurdle for this theory.
A specific, persistent theory involves a local construction worker who was known to have been involved in a relationship with Suzie Streeter. This individual was questioned by police early on, and some people close to the case have expressed suspicions about him. However, he has never been charged, and no concrete evidence has ever directly linked him to the disappearance. The theory suggests he might have had a key or been let into the house, which could explain the lack of forced entry.
Another chilling possibility is the claim made by Robert Craig Cox, a convicted kidnapper and murderer who was imprisoned in Texas. In 1992, Cox was living in Springfield. He claimed to know what happened to the Springfield Three. He told a reporter that the women were buried near a local landfill and that their bodies would never be found. He even offered to reveal the location if he was granted immunity from prosecution. Police investigated his claims, but he never provided enough verifiable information to lead to a discovery, and his claims were ultimately dismissed as unreliable, possibly a ploy for attention. However, the fact that a convicted murderer was in the area and made such a claim adds a layer of darkness to the mystery.
There’s also the less likely, but still considered, theory of a voluntary disappearance. Perhaps the women, for reasons unknown, decided to leave their lives behind. However, this theory struggles immensely with the facts: leaving their cars, all their belongings, their pets, and having no contact with anyone for decades. It seems highly improbable for three individuals to make such a pact and execute it so perfectly without a single trace emerging.
The Unending Agony – A Family’s Fight for Answers
For the families of the Springfield Three, particularly Janis McCall, Stacy’s mother, the past three decades have been an unending nightmare of uncertainty and grief. Janis has dedicated her life to finding answers for her daughter and her friends. She has tirelessly campaigned, worked with law enforcement, appeared on countless television shows and documentaries, and kept the case in the public eye.
The emotional toll on the families has been immense. To not know what happened to your loved ones, to have no body to bury, no closure, is a unique kind of torture. Every anniversary, every new lead that goes nowhere, every passing year without answers, is a fresh wave of pain. The families have had to live with the constant speculation, the bizarre theories, and the chilling reality that their loved ones simply vanished.
The case of The Springfield Three is a stark reminder of how quickly life can change, and how a seemingly ordinary night can spiral into a terrifying, inexplicable mystery. It highlights the vastness of the unknown, and the limitations of even the most thorough investigations when a perpetrator leaves absolutely no trace.
What truly happened to Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall on that night in 1992? Did they leave voluntarily? Were they abducted by a stranger? Or did someone they know, someone with a key, commit the perfect crime? The unlocked door, the broken porch light, the vanished key, and the complete absence of any evidence – these are the haunting pieces of The Springfield Three puzzle. They went to sleep in their beds, and then, in a matter of hours, simply ceased to exist, leaving behind only questions that echo in the quiet streets of Springfield, Missouri.
What do you think happened to The Springfield Three? Let me know your theories in the comments below. And until our next strange, dark, and mysterious tale, stay curious, and stay safe.
