In July 2023, Alicia Navarro walked into a police station and identified herself. In September 2025, Crystal Rogers’ mother stood in court after a murder conviction and still had to ask where her daughter was. A disappearance can reach an answer without every question reaching the same end.
These eight stories follow the events that changed the search: a person coming forward, a vehicle recovered, remains identified, an inquest or a verdict. Some concern continuing missing-person searches. Others are accounts of deaths with established findings. Each has its own chronology and its own remaining questions.
Eight cases and the discoveries that changed them
Noah Donohoe: six days of searching, six years to an inquest
For six days in June 2020, searchers looked for 14-year-old Noah Donohoe. His body was eventually found in an underground water tunnel in north Belfast. A post-mortem established drowning, but the discovery left questions about how he had reached the culvert and whether he could have been protected from it.
In September 2026, the inquest jury found that failures in the Department for Infrastructure’s management of access to the culvert possibly contributed to his death. It distinguished those failures from the police investigation: Noah had died before he was reported missing, but later investigative errors limited the conclusions jurors could reach.
His mother, Fiona, attended every day of the proceedings. Friends remembered the classical-music playlists he made and the books he recommended.
Alicia Navarro: the missing teenager who identified herself
In July 2023, an 18-year-old woman walked into a Montana police station alone and asked to be removed from a missing-juvenile list. She identified herself as Alicia Navarro, who had disappeared from Arizona at 14 in 2019. Glendale police checked her identity and announced that she had been found alive.
That visit ended the search for Alicia, but investigators still had to examine the years in between. She had been living with Edmund Davis in Havre. During their investigation, officers discovered child sexual abuse material on his phone. In February 2025, he received a 100-year sentence with 50 years suspended, with parole eligibility after 25 years.
That conviction concerned the material on his device. It was not a conviction for Alicia’s disappearance. The distinction matters to her story: she is a living person who came forward, and the criminal outcome should not be turned into a claim that a court established how she originally left Arizona.
Susan Powell: an empty house and a disputed camping trip
The first warning came from an ordinary missed appointment. On December 7, 2009, Susan Powell did not bring her children to childcare. Neither she nor her husband, Joshua, had arrived at work, and no one could reach them. Police entered their West Valley City home fearing carbon monoxide poisoning. The house was empty.
Joshua returned that evening with their two sons, but without Susan. He said he had taken the boys camping around midnight, leaving her asleep or getting ready for bed. Susan’s family foundation records that account as his claim; it does not establish where Susan was after she was last seen at home on December 6.
Utah’s official case record says investigators suspected Joshua had information about her disappearance. He died without resolving it. Extensive searches have not located Susan. The two dates describe different milestones: December 6 was her last reported sighting, while December 7 was the day her absence brought police to the house.
Kiely Rodni: the search returned to the water
Kiely Rodni’s mother said her daughter’s final text told her she planned to leave a party soon and come home. Instead, both the 16-year-old and her Honda CR-V disappeared after the gathering near Truckee’s Prosser Family Campground in the early hours of August 6, 2022.
The nearby reservoir was inside the search area. Authorities had already used divers and sonar there when the independent dive group Adventures With Purpose located a submerged vehicle on August 21. The body recovered from it was identified as Kiely two days later. The place that finally yielded her had been part of the search from the beginning.
On October 13, the Nevada County Sheriff’s Office announced that her death was accidental. The pathologist had found drowning, and the investigation had uncovered no other information suggesting foul play. The recovery and the later finding belong together: the car’s discovery explained where she was, and the subsequent investigation established the official manner of death.
Kristin Smart: a conviction, followed by another search
Kristin Smart attended an off-campus party in May 1996 and never returned to her Cal Poly dormitory. She was a 19-year-old freshman. Fellow student Paul Flores became central to the investigation, but it took until 2021 for investigators to arrest him.
A jury convicted Flores of first-degree murder in October 2022. In March 2023, he was sentenced to 25 years to life. The conviction survived an appeal in October 2025, and the California Supreme Court denied his petition for review in January 2026.
The court proceedings did not end the effort to find Kristin. In May 2026, investigators searched another Arroyo Grande property tied to the case, using soil testing and ground-penetrating radar before excavating. The sheriff’s office later reported collecting items of evidentiary value, but no human remains. Nearly thirty years after the disappearance, a murder conviction and an unfinished search existed side by side.
Crystal Rogers: a sentence could not answer her mother’s question
Crystal Rogers disappeared on July 3, 2015. Two days later, her car was found beside Kentucky’s Bluegrass Parkway with her purse and phone still inside. She was 35 and the mother of five children.
Ten years later, a jury convicted her boyfriend, Brooks Houck, of her murder. Prosecutors had persuaded jurors that she was killed at the Houck family farm, although her remains had not been recovered. In September 2025, a judge sentenced him to life in prison.
At the sentencing, Crystal’s mother, Sherry Ballard, asked him to tell her where her daughter was. The verdict had established criminal responsibility; it had not supplied a place for searchers to find Crystal. The FBI’s continuing appeal now asks for information that could locate her remains. That is the outstanding search, rather than an absence of a murder verdict.
Patrice Endres: what was left inside the salon
Patrice Endres’ lunch was uneaten. Her car keys were still at the salon, but her vehicle had been moved and money was missing. On April 15, 2004, she was last seen just before 11:30 a.m. at Tamber’s Trim ’N Tan near Cumming, Georgia. Shortly after noon, she was discovered missing.
The 38-year-old’s disappearance became a homicide investigation after skeletal remains found behind a church in Dawson County on December 6, 2005, were identified as hers. The recovery answered where her remains were, without identifying the person responsible.
One personal possession remains part of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation’s appeal: her unrecovered wedding ring. It consisted of two bands joined together, with a marquise diamond at the center. Investigators hope recognition of that ring could lead them to her killer. The salon’s interrupted working day and that missing piece of jewelry remain specific leads in an unsolved homicide.
Amelia Earhart: the words that reached the Itasca
The Coast Guard cutter Itasca was supporting Amelia Earhart’s 1937 attempt to fly around the world. Its radio operators kept a log. The aircraft’s call sign, KHAQQ, appears in a record that survives long after contact with the plane was lost.
Across July 1 and 2, the crew reported difficulty communicating, a low altitude of 1,000 feet and, at one point, a position 200 miles from Howland Island. At approximately 8:43 a.m. on July 2, the ship received the last communication recorded in the log. It referred to a line of position, 157–337.
The National Archives preserves the log among radio operator Leo Bellarts’ papers. It allows readers to follow what the ship received, including the trouble establishing communication. It cannot supply the aircraft’s eventual location. Of all the objects in these cases, this one preserves something unusually direct: words transmitted from a journey that never reached its destination.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are all eight people still missing?
No. Alicia Navarro was found alive. Noah Donohoe, Kiely Rodni and Patrice Endres were recovered after death. Susan Powell remains missing; searches for Kristin Smart’s and Crystal Rogers’ remains continue. Earhart’s radio record documents her final contact, rather than a recovery.
What did Noah Donohoe’s inquest establish?
The September 2026 findings identified access-management failures and later investigative errors. His cause of death was drowning.
Was Kiely Rodni’s death ruled a homicide?
No. The sheriff’s October 2022 announcement classified it as accidental drowning.
Did the 2026 search recover Kristin Smart?
No. The sheriff’s May update reported evidence collected during the search, but no human remains recovered.
Why is Patrice Endres still listed as an unsolved case?
Her remains were identified in 2005, but the GBI continues to seek information about her killing. Recovery and identification did not solve the homicide.
Sources & References
The following resources were consulted to verify and update this article.
- ITV News UTV — Mum’s tribute to ‘greatest gift’ but says PSNI and Department failed Noah
September 2026 inquest findings, investigation failures and evidence from family and friends. - ABC News — Arizona teen missing since 2019 found ‘safe, happy and healthy’ in small Montana town
Police announcement that Alicia was found alive. - Utah Department of Public Safety — Susan Marie POWELL
Official continuing missing-person record. - Nevada County Sheriff’s Office via YubaNet — Kiely Rodni’s death ruled accidental
Official accidental-drowning finding. - San Luis Obispo County District Attorney — Paul Flores has been sentenced to 25 years to life in prison for the 1996 murder of 19-year-old Kristin Denise Smart
Official murder conviction and sentence. - WKU Public Radio — ‘Tell me where my daughter is’: mother of Crystal Rogers speaks as Brooks Houck is sentenced to life
2025 murder verdict and sentence. - Georgia Bureau of Investigation — Unsolved Homicide: Patrice Endres
Disappearance, recovered remains and unsolved homicide. - US National Archives — Radio Log of the Last Communications of Amelia Earhart
National Archives description and digitized log pages; the narrative uses the Archives’ transcription and chronology. - Susan Cox Powell Foundation — About Susan
Family account of the last sighting, missed childcare and Joshua’s camping claim. - Arizona’s Family — Montana man linked to previously missing Glendale teen sentenced in child porn case
February 2025 sentence for Edmund Davis; distinguishes the images case from Alicia’s disappearance. - ABC News — Body found in reservoir is that of missing teen Kiely Rodni: Police
August 2022 recovery, identification and search chronology. - San Luis Obispo County District Attorney — Paul Flores’ Petition for Review of his Conviction Denied by California Supreme Court
January 2026 review denial and preceding appeal decision. - ABC News — New search warrant in Kristin Smart case, decades after 19-year-old disappeared
Party, disappearance and May 2026 search announcement. - Edhat — SLO Sheriff States Evidence Recovered but No Remains Found in Search for Kristin Smart
May 19, 2026 report of the sheriff’s post-search statement. - FBI — Crystal Rogers
Continuing appeal for information to locate her remains after the murder verdict.





