Blog

Vehicles, Routes and Later Findings: Six Disappearance and Death Cases

8 min readMay 8, 2026

In a Jeep on a Washington logging road, investigators found a ticket for American Beauty. It was one of the few dated records of Leah Roberts’s trip from North Carolina. It could tell the sheriff’s office what time a purchase had been made in Bellingham. It could not tell her family where to find her.

Five of the searches below reached a vehicle before they reached an answer about its driver. Four drivers remain missing. The fifth, Brandon Lawson, was identified years later. The sixth case follows a different kind of journey: Tiffany Valiante died after a train struck her, and her family disputed the ruling on her death.

Six Cases Involving Vehicles, Routes and Unanswered Questions

Maura Murray

At an ATM on February 9, 2004, a camera recorded Maura Murray in a dark jacket and jeans. The FBI identifies that footage as the last recorded sighting in its account of her disappearance. Murray was twenty-one, a nursing student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and a runner who liked hiking in New Hampshire’s White Mountains. She had left Amherst without telling others about the trip. Her familiarity with the mountains offers some context for the drive, but no one could give investigators a destination she had named.

At about 7:30 that evening her black Saturn went off Route 112 in Haverhill, New Hampshire, and became stuck. The roads were snowy. When police arrived, they found the car without Murray. The location gave investigators a road and a time around which to seek witnesses. Beyond that point the FBI’s appeal has no further sighting to report.

Eighteen years later, officers again went out on foot along Route 112. In July 2022 New Hampshire authorities announced a ground search in Landaff and Easton with help from the state Fish and Game Department. Their announcement specified that the search had not been prompted by new information. Returning to a road was part of the work still to be done, rather than a public claim that Murray had been seen there. The FBI released an age-progressed image in 2024 and continues to seek information.

Read the individual story: What Happened to Maura Murray? Inside the Unsolved 2004 Disappearance.

Brandon Lawson

Brandon Lawson was able to tell a dispatcher something that Murray had not told anyone before her journey: which highway to look on. In the early hours of August 9, 2013, he called 911 in Texas and said he was on U.S. 277 between Bronte and Abilene and needed police. According to the Texas Department of Public Safety, responding deputies found his truck roughly four miles south of Bronte. Part of it was still in the roadway. A relative who had also received a call asking for help came to the area. Neither the truck nor the relative’s arrival put the deputies in contact with Lawson.

Years later a foot search produced a different kind of lead. Members of the group that searched in January 2022 described finding clothing and alerting the Texas Rangers. A subsequent search recovered human remains. In December 2024, the participants reported that DNA testing had identified those remains as Lawson’s. The announcement changed what his family could say about the man who had called for help. The identification did not supply an account of how he died. The state’s roadside appeal still describes the search as it stood before the identification.

Read the individual story: Brandon Lawson: The Disappearance and Later Identification.

Bryce Laspisa

Bryce Laspisa’s mother had heard from her son during his drive from Northern California toward the family home in Laguna Niguel. A Sierra College student, he was traveling south in a beige Toyota Highlander. At about two in the morning on August 30, 2013, he called to say that he was tired and planned to stop and sleep. According to the Charley Project’s case account, he told her he would call when he woke up.

A few hours later the Highlander was found on its side in a ravine off Lake Hughes Road near Castaic Lake. The rear window was smashed. His phone, wallet and laptop were among the belongings inside. Those discoveries gave his family an explanation for why a call placed to his phone could no longer reliably reach him. They did not put him on a particular trail or road. Searchers examined the surrounding area without locating him. The stop he had described to his mother was an intention. No public account establishes that he ever slept in the car or how he left it.

Read the individual story: Bryce Laspisa Disappearance — The Strange Drive Before He Vanished.

Daniel Robinson

On June 23, 2021, Daniel Robinson left a remote work site in Buckeye, Arizona. A hydrogeologist, he had been assigned to a well project in the desert. His family wanted searchers in the air. According to ABC15’s reporting on the police report, the family requested a helicopter search on June 24. Police approved it the next day. The Civil Air Patrol was contacted on July 7.

It was a rancher on the ground who located Robinson’s Jeep on July 19. It lay overturned in a ravine. Police told ABC15 that the terrain had screened the vehicle from view overhead. Robinson’s boots, phone, wallet and keys were found in the Jeep. Their recovery gave searchers a specific part of the desert to examine almost four weeks after he had left the job site.

His father, David Robinson, organized searches with volunteers, and the family hired an investigator. The family challenged the interpretation of the wreck and raised the possibility that the scene had been staged. Police have said they did not suspect foul play. Neither the police assessment nor the family’s concerns account for where Robinson went. He remains missing.

Read the individual story: Daniel Robinson Disappearance — The Jeep Found in the Arizona Desert.

Leah Roberts

The papers in Leah Roberts’s white Jeep Cherokee let investigators reconstruct part of a trip across the country. Roberts, twenty-three, left Durham, North Carolina, on March 9, 2000, without telling anyone her destination. On March 18 the Jeep was found abandoned on a logging road in Whatcom County, Washington.

A gasoline receipt from Brooks, Oregon, recorded a purchase early on March 13. A movie ticket placed another purchase at the Bellis Fair Mall in Bellingham, Washington, that afternoon. The Whatcom County Sheriff’s Office was able to give the time, 2:10 p.m., and the film, American Beauty. These were two places where someone might remember a traveler and a much narrower period in which to ask. A ticket can establish when it was sold without identifying the person who sat through the film.

Cat food inside the Jeep suggested to investigators that Roberts might have brought her kitten from North Carolina. The sheriff’s office presents that as a possibility. It still asks for information about Roberts herself after her departure. The route supplied by the receipts runs out several days before the discovery on the logging road.

Read the individual story: The Leah Roberts Road Trip Mystery That Still Doesn’t Make Sense.

Tiffany Valiante

Tiffany Valiante’s family knew where she died. On July 12, 2015, a New Jersey Transit train struck the eighteen-year-old in Galloway Township, nearly four miles from home. Her father had found her cellphone near the edge of the family property while looking for her. The question was how she had covered the distance between those places and come to be on the tracks.

The medical examiner ruled her death a suicide. Her parents disputed that finding. In 2017 WHYY reported that the family had sought investigative files and consulted outside specialists. Her mother had walked the roads between home and the tracks and found shoes the family identified as Tiffany’s. The parents asked that the manner of death be changed to undetermined. Their allegation that another person had been involved remained an allegation.

In April 2026, Out In Jersey reported that a New Jersey judge had dismissed a later lawsuit brought by the family under the state’s Crime Victims’ Bill of Rights. A court’s disposition of that suit and an eyewitness account of Tiffany’s final journey are different things. Neither the family’s challenge nor the dismissal establishes an abduction. There was no abandoned car in this case, and Tiffany is not a missing person.

Read the individual story: What Happened to Tiffany Valiante? The Evidence Trail That Still Doesn’t Add Up.

What the Comparisons Can Show

A search near Castaic began with a call about a planned rest stop. In Arizona an overturned Jeep eluded an aerial search before a rancher found it on the ground. In Washington the items inside a vehicle gave investigators dates and locations hundreds of miles apart. Each discovery changed where people could look or whom they could ask. Only Lawson’s case produced a later identification, after a search on foot and a wait for DNA results.

Research Sources

The records and reports below distinguish the original searches from later findings.

  1. FBI — Maura Murray official notice
    Confirms the crash location and missing status.
  2. Texas DPS — Brandon Lawson historical case record
    Documents the original roadside investigation; read alongside the later identification.
  3. Navigating Advocacy — Brandon Lawson: Confirmed
    Search participants report DNA confirmation of recovered remains in December 2024.
  4. The Charley Project — Bryce David Laspisa
    Describes the recovered Highlander and continuing disappearance.
  5. The Charley Project — Daniel Cornelius Robinson
    Separates reported vehicle findings from police and family interpretations.
  6. Whatcom County Sheriff’s Office — Missing: Leah Roberts
    Official departure and Jeep-discovery dates.
  7. WHYY — Tiffany Valiante death ruling disputed
    Reports the train fatality, suicide ruling and family’s challenge.
  8. New Hampshire authorities’ July 2022 statement, reproduced by Murray’s family
    Describes the Landaff and Easton ground search.
  9. ABC15 — Buckeye police release their Robinson report
    Reports the search requests and the rancher’s July 19 discovery.
  10. Out In Jersey — court dismisses Valiante family’s later lawsuit
    Reports the April 2026 ruling on the family’s civil suit.

Explore this topic

Explore more Blog →

Leave a Reply

Continue the story

Keep going

Four more stories connected to the case you just finished.

View all