Hexham Market Place and Moot Hall, October 16, 2012. Later location context photograph, not an image of the Pollock family. Photo: David Dixon / Geograph. CC BY-SA 2.0.
John Pollock believed in reincarnation before his daughters died. When his wife Florence became pregnant again, he told people their daughters would return. Florence did not share that belief. In October 1958 she gave birth to twins. The girls were named Gillian and Jennifer.
Listen to “The Pollock Twins” on Spreaker.
The case associated with the twins began with observations made at home. A mark on a child’s skin, a preference for one toy over another, a moment of alarm near a car. To anyone outside the family, these episodes might have gone unremarked. Inside the Pollock household, each had a possible counterpart in the lives of two other girls.
The sisters who died in Hexham
In May 1957, Joanna Pollock, eleven, and Jacqueline, six, were walking to church in Hexham, Northumberland, with another child. A driver struck them. All three children died. John and Florence had raised the girls in Hexham, where the family ran a grocery and milk-delivery business.
The comparison that mattered most to John was there before his twins were old enough to speak. Jennifer had a mark on her forehead. Jacqueline had carried a scar near the same place after an injury when she was small. John and Florence also reported that Jennifer had a mark at her waist that reminded them of one on Jacqueline. The inference that the marks connected the children belonged to the parents. A physician could examine Jennifer later without being able to establish what the resemblance meant.
The toys the parents remembered
John and Florence described an occasion when the twins were shown things that had belonged to their sisters. According to their account, Gillian reached for Joanna’s doll and Jennifer for Jacqueline’s. Gillian also laid claim to a toy clothes wringer. A small household object had acquired two histories, each involving a little girl who considered it hers.
How much could a child have learned about a dead sibling in a home where the sibling’s toys were still kept? The parents believed the recognitions were unexpected. To test that interpretation, an observer would need to know what the twins had already seen or heard, and what happened on occasions when they chose differently. No one had been making that sort of record as the children grew up.
Florence also described the girls holding tight to her hands near traffic. She offered a possibility of her own. After losing her daughters on a road, she might have communicated her own fear to the twins.
Timeline of Events
- May 1957: Joanna and Jacqueline Pollock die after a car strikes them and another child in Hexham.
- 4 October 1958: Florence gives birth to Gillian and Jennifer. John had already expressed his belief that the older girls would return.
- Early childhood: The parents report resemblances, remarks and responses to toys that they connect with the sisters. These are family recollections, not observations recorded by Stevenson as they happened.
- August 1963: Stevenson first meets the family, interviews the parents and examines Jennifer’s marks.
- 1967 and 1978: Further visits allow follow-up, but cannot recreate the circumstances of the earlier incidents.
When a researcher visited
Ian Stevenson, a psychiatrist who collected accounts of children said to remember previous lives, learned of the Pollock family through news coverage. He first visited in 1963. Gillian and Jennifer were nearly five. He could speak with both parents and see the marks on Jennifer’s skin. For the earlier conversations and incidents he depended on recollections.
That timing makes a difference. The sight of a birthmark could confirm that Jennifer had one. It could not independently establish what her sister’s scar looked like or how anyone had reacted on first seeing it. Stevenson maintained contact with the family and returned in later years. A longer acquaintance gave him more opportunities to ask questions, while leaving that first gap intact.
In his account the children made a limited number of remarks during childhood. Neither twin supplied a sustained account of another life. Later writers have often joined the small episodes together into a continuous story. The original question was more modest and harder to resolve. Why did those particular similarities stand out to the people who raised all four girls?
What Doesn’t Add Up: the missing independent record
Stevenson gave weight to differences between the twins that seemed to correspond to differences between their older sisters. Critics point to the source of the comparisons. The people who knew Joanna and Jacqueline best were also the people raising Gillian and Jennifer, choosing which moments to remember and telling the investigator what they meant.
Nothing in that objection requires accusing the family of fabrication. It describes a limit that an honest, detailed memory still has. John’s belief was part of the story before the children were born. It cannot also serve as independent confirmation of what the family later saw.
FAQ
Who were the Pollock twins?
Gillian and Jennifer were born in 1958, after their older sisters Joanna and Jacqueline died in a traffic collision in Hexham.
What did their parents report?
They described marks on Jennifer’s skin, responses to familiar objects and behavior they associated with their older daughters.
Did Stevenson witness the original incidents?
He visited when the twins were nearly five. He examined the marks and interviewed the parents, who supplied the accounts of earlier events.
Did the case establish reincarnation?
No. The family’s observations and Stevenson’s interpretation do not establish that memories passed from one child to another.
Research Sources
The following resources were consulted to verify and update this article.
- International Centre for Reincarnation Research, Pollock twins — Summarizes Stevenson’s interviews, their dates, the parents’ observations and the limits of the testimony.
- Society for Psychical Research, Psi Encyclopedia — Describes the birthmarks, toys and the father’s pre-existing belief, and presents criticisms of the case.
- Skeptic, a review of reincarnation research — Distinguishes reported resemblances in this family from explicit autobiographical memories.
Related stories
- The Somerton Man investigation
- The Green Children of Woolpit
- The Mary Celeste mystery
- The Wyoming Incident: a fictional broadcast-hijack story
Explore this topic
Watch This Story on YouTube
Prefer to watch? See the full story on our YouTube channel.





