Illustrative cover artwork; not a documentary photograph of the people, location or events described in this article.
On December 5, 1945, five Navy bombers left Fort Lauderdale for a navigation exercise. They carried fourteen men. The instructor, Lieutenant Charles Taylor, had flown combat missions in the Pacific and logged more than 2,500 hours in the air. This was his first time leading this particular exercise from Fort Lauderdale. A mistake about the position of the aircraft would give all his experience a difficult question to answer. Which way lay Florida?
The radio record of Flight 19
A pilot on another flight heard Taylor report trouble with both compasses. Taylor could see broken land below and thought it might be the Florida Keys. That identification mattered. The route back to the Florida mainland from the Keys was quite different from the route home from the Bahamas, where the exercise had taken the aircraft.
The transmissions heard that afternoon were incomplete. They put the crews in contact with people trying to help, but never put the aircraft at a place rescuers could reach. A Navy historical reconstruction identifies disorientation, dwindling fuel and worsening weather as the likely chain of events. The exact place where the Avengers came down remains unknown.
The aircraft sent to look for them
One of the rescue planes, a PBM Mariner with thirteen men aboard, also failed to return. Grouping it with the five missing Avengers gives the impression of six identical disappearances. The search plane left a different trail. A witness saw fire in the sky, and radar evidence supported a sudden loss. The Navy historian considered an in-flight fire or explosion probable. Searchers never recovered wreckage that could establish the precise cause of either loss.
The ship that left Barbados
The Navy had lost another crew on an Atlantic voyage nearly three decades earlier. On March 4, 1918, USS Cyclops left Barbados for Baltimore. Its cargo was manganese ore. The Navy’s historical account lists 306 people aboard, including passengers. The ship sent no known distress message.
The last confirmed port gives the voyage a starting point, and the destination tells us where people expected the ship to arrive. Neither tells us where along the passage it went down. In the absence of an identified wreck, putting a dot at the center of a triangle on a map would make the evidence look more precise than it is.
The ghost ship off North Carolina
The five-masted Carroll A. Deering, on its way from Barbados to Virginia in January 1921, left more to examine. A crewman told the keeper of the Cape Lookout lightship that the schooner had lost its anchors. Two days later a Coast Guardsman at Cape Hatteras saw the ship aground on the shoals. It still had sail set. Its lifeboats were gone.
Heavy seas kept rescuers from boarding until February 4. They found food laid out and discovered that personal effects, navigational equipment and papers were missing. They found nobody aboard. A subsequent message in a bottle purporting to explain the crew’s disappearance was exposed as a hoax. The wreck itself had never been geographically mysterious. It lay on North Carolina’s Outer Banks, well north of the familiar Miami–Bermuda–Puerto Rico outline.
What is the Bermuda Triangle?
The name is commonly applied to a stretch of the western North Atlantic. NOAA points out that no official chart defines its boundaries. Neither a historian nor a statistician can count losses within it without first deciding where to draw the lines. Moving those lines far enough to include the Deering would change the question.
Weather and navigation already give mariners reason for care. NOAA describes tropical storms, changing conditions around the Gulf Stream and shallow waters around the islands. Its conclusion is that evidence does not show mysterious losses happening more often here than in other large, busy parts of the ocean. That leaves room for a real unanswered question about a particular crew.
Frequently asked questions
What happened to Flight 19?
The five Avengers probably ran short of fuel after losing their bearings. The radio record helps explain how that could have happened. The location where the fourteen men and their aircraft were lost remains unconfirmed.
How many ships and planes disappeared in the Triangle?
There is no official boundary or agreed case inventory from which to calculate such a total. A count of famous stories cannot establish that the region is unusually dangerous.
Was the Carroll A. Deering found in the Triangle?
The Coast Guard sighted it on Diamond Shoals off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina. The mystery concerned the whereabouts of its crew.
Research Sources
The following resources were consulted to verify and update this article.
- NOAA National Ocean Service, What is the Bermuda Triangle?. Explains the lack of official boundaries and the absence of evidence for an unusually high disappearance rate.
- Naval History and Heritage Command, H-057-4, pages 27–33. Reconstructs the Flight 19 radio exchanges and evaluates the different evidence for the loss of the search plane.
- Naval History and Heritage Command, H-Gram 016. Documents the last port, cargo and people aboard USS Cyclops.
- Cape Hatteras National Seashore, the Carroll A. Deering. Identifies the North Carolina wreck site, the delayed boarding and what rescuers found.
🔎 Related Mystery Power Posts:
🔎 If you found this Bermuda Triangle mystery interesting, the author suggests these real mysteries next:This story is part of our growing collection of strange real mysteries, disappearances, and unbelievable cases that continue to puzzle investigators and historians today. 👉 Explore more here: Bizarre & Unbelievable Stories
- Flight MH370 Disappearance — The Plane That Vanished Without a Trace
- Gone Between the Waves — The Modern Mystery of Vanishing Ships
- D.B. Cooper Mystery — The Man Who Hijacked a Plane and Vanished
- Mary Celeste Mystery — The Ghost Ship Found Adrift With No Crew
Watch This Story on YouTube
Prefer to watch? See the full story on our YouTube channel.





